Just Because He’s Black, Doesn’t Mean He’s Here To Rob A House

Thank you Simon McCormack

Hammond Police Break Window and Tase Man!
Family files excessive force lawsuit against Indiana police for their actions during a traffic stop for a seat belt violation.(10-7-14)

‘Just Because He’s Black, Doesn’t Mean He’s Here To Rob A House’

An interaction between Washington, D.C. police, a black handyman and a white lawyer could shine a light on the way race affects people’s interactions with authorities.

The video above shows Dennis Stucky seated on the curb in Foxhall, a wealthy neighborhood in D.C last week. A black female officer has stopped Stucky in connection with a reported burglary in an adjacent neighborhood three-quarters-of-a-mile away.

Although the alarm was sounding in an adjacent subdivision — three-quarters of a mile away by car — one of the officers ordered the 64-year-old man to sit on the curb while she put on disposable gloves and prepared to search him.

Jody Westby, a resident and lawyer, rushed to Stucky’s defense, angrily telling the officers that Stucky had been a neighborhood fix-it man for 30 years and that they were not at the right house. The officers reluctantly freed Stucky, who lives in Southeast and said he feels he was stopped “because I’m black.”
“Just because he’s black, doesn’t mean he’s here to rob a house,” Westby says in the video, which was filmed by Westby’s housekeeper.

Stucky was released by the police who said they stopped him because he was carrying bags and the burglary had just been called in.

District police spokesperson Gwendolyn Crump said “there’s no misconduct by the officer in that video.”

What is most interesting about the encounter, is how confidently Westby behaves toward the officers and how much leeway they give her during the incident.

“The level of comfort with which she communicates with the officers due to her knowledge of the law and lack of fear of retribution offers a lesson about how the intersection of race, class and privilege can impact the interactions between police officers and some residents,” Yates writes.

“Westby proceeds to chastise the officer for harassing Stucky, and tells them they need to leave. She’s pointing her fingers and gesturing toward the car window. That’s the type of behavior that coming from many other people would be considered dangerous, threatening or violent in some way.”


2 thoughts on “Just Because He’s Black, Doesn’t Mean He’s Here To Rob A House

  1. “The level of comfort with which she communicates with the officers due to her knowledge of the law and lack of fear of retribution ”

    Hubby commented about Jody Wesby’s directness toward LE.
    His brother who worked with the LA Co. Fire Dept (now retired) had co-workers who dreaded working in Beverly Hills/Bel-air area. (any prominent area) because they (white firemen) weren’t looked upon as the authority. They rather work in “other” neighborhoods, where people listen to them and view them as a leader.

    People like Jody Wesby understands her privileged which we all should have.
    LE/fire workers work for us, we the people. Uh, but funny how a select few can exercise that tone.
    He (hubby) went on to say, that if he were to tell the police to get out of his community, he’d be faced down if not; shot.
    Don’t get me wrong, I am glad that she defended Mr. Stucky. I know there are more Jody’s but not enough to go around and especially not in minority neighborhoods. My bad, Trayvon wasn’t in a minority neighborhood, neither were plenty others who have been harassed if not killed.

    L2S, sorry to rant; we’ll chalk this as my initiation chat. 🙂 So glad you’re here!

    • Thanks Peni, I’ve always loved your you train of thought and point blank, straight forwardness. You’re absolutely right, privilege and lording it over. I know I couldn’t tell a cop “I pay your salary” and not be thrown against a car and handcuffed.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s